Fiber Reinforcement in Precast Concrete Fence Panels
When fibers earn a place in a fence panel mix, which kind does what, and what changes at the mixer, the mold and the test bench when you add them.
Fiber reinforcement is worth adding to precast concrete fence panels when a yard has a specific problem fibers solve, such as panels cracking or spalling as they come out of the mold, or shrinkage cracks, and the National Precast Concrete Association says there may be little advantage otherwise. Microfibers control early plastic shrinkage cracking and are not structural. Macrofibers can carry load after cracking, but replacing a panel's rebar with them is an engineering decision, not a mix tweak.
When do fibers earn a place in a fence panel mix?
Fibers earn a place in a fence panel mix when they fix a problem the yard can name. The NPCA Fibers White Paper gives a product that keeps cracking or spalling as it is removed from the mold as its first example, and random cracks from drying or plastic shrinkage as its second. Both are familiar in a fence yard, where thin panels are stripped and lifted early.
The same white paper says that if no specification calls for fibers and the plant has no handling stress or shrinkage cracking issues, there may be little advantage to adding them. So a producer should write down the defect first, then run production trials to find which fiber, at what dosage, removes it. A yard that logs defects, as described in our guide to quality control for a fence yard, already has the evidence it needs to make that call.
What kinds of fiber are there?
ASTM C1116, the standard specification for fiber-reinforced concrete, sorts fibers into four types: Type I steel under ASTM A820, Type II glass under ASTM C1666, Type III synthetic under ASTM D7508, and Type IV natural under ASTM D7357. NPCA says that in North America the use of fibers for precast applications must comply with ASTM C1116.
For a fence producer the practical split is size. NPCA's Fiber Reinforcement Best Practices tech note defines microfibers as less than 0.3 millimeters in diameter and macrofibers as greater than 0.3 millimeters, and says suppliers can blend both in one mix.
| Synthetic microfibers | Synthetic macrofibers | |
|---|---|---|
| Diameter (NPCA) | Less than 0.3 mm | Greater than 0.3 mm |
| Typical length (Precast Today) | 1/2 inch to 3/4 inch (12 to 19 mm) | 1 1/2 inches to 2 inches (38 to 50 mm) |
| Typical dosage (Precast Today) | 0.5 to 1.5 lb/yd3 | 3.0 to 15 lb/yd3 |
| Main job | Plastic shrinkage crack control | Post-crack toughness and limited structural capacity when properly designed |
| Can replace steel reinforcement? | Never, per NPCA | Can be considered where codes or project specifications allow |
Dosage ranges vary by product and application, so the fiber supplier's data sheet and the plant's own trials set the number, not a table.
What do fibers do, and what do they not do?
Fibers bridge cracks and hold concrete together, but they do not do the job of continuous rebar. NPCA's Precast Today magazine says synthetic microfibers resist plastic shrinkage cracking better than welded wire reinforcement, yet do not resist cracks widening from drying shrinkage, structural load or other stress.
The white paper draws the same line. Fibers are discontinuous and randomly distributed, so they spread tensile stress through the concrete well, but they may not handle the concentrated tensile forces that primary reinforcement carries. Conventional reinforcement governs the global capacity of the member, which for a fence panel means spanning between posts.
Can fibers replace the rebar in a fence panel?
Replacing a fence panel's rebar with fibers is a question for a structural engineer, and NPCA says so directly. Its white paper states that neither ACI 318 nor the AASHTO bridge specifications have any provision for fiber in lieu of reinforcing steel, apart from steel fiber beams being exempted from minimum shear reinforcement in ACI 318-08 and later, and that any replacement should be evaluated by a structural engineer.
Where a design does use macrofibers structurally, Precast Today describes the method: ASTM C1609 measures the post-crack residual strength, and that is converted to moment capacity under ACI 544.4R, the guide to design with fiber-reinforced concrete. The same article notes that fibers have not yet been implemented as a complete substitute for conventional reinforcement in precast, with ASTM C1765 for steel fiber pipe as a foundation for future use.
How do fibers change the mix?
Fibers stiffen the mix, and the fix is admixture, not water. NPCA's tech note gives a rough estimate of about an inch of slump loss for every three pounds of fiber per cubic yard, and recommends superplasticizers or mid-range water reducers to keep slump without changing the water-cement ratio. It also warns that a mix with lower slump may still flow adequately once it is in the form.
Fibers also need more paste to coat them. The white paper lists three ways to get it: more cement and water, a change in coarse aggregate ratios, or a change in the fine to coarse ratio. For producers using self-consolidating concrete, it adds that fiber mixes are more sensitive to water and that a batch plant unable to measure within ±1% of the desired ingredients may not achieve an SCC-fiber combination. Our guide to wet cast concrete for decorative fence panels covers the base mix these adjustments start from.
How do you batch fibers without balling?
Fibers ball when they go into a mix that is too dry or short on fines, or into an empty mixer. NPCA's tech note says fibers are rarely added at the start of batching and are usually added with the aggregates or near the end, and that a batch with fibers should be mixed at high speed for at least 3 to 5 minutes, or at least 70 revolutions in a mixer truck.
Pre-weighed degradable bags, water-soluble pucks, blowers and fluid dispensers are all in use, and the white paper notes most precasters still add fibers to each batch by hand. NPCA recommends a test trial to confirm the mix supports the fiber type and dosage before full production.
What happens at the textured face of the panel?
A fence panel is judged on its formed face, and NPCA says fibers should not change it. The white paper states that exposed surfaces may look and finish differently depending on dosage, but that compressive strength and mold surface finishes should not be affected.
Any open, troweled surface is where fibers tend to show. Precast Today says stiff fibers tend to protrude more than flexible ones, and that a torch can burn off synthetic fibers on the surface only after the concrete has reached its hardened properties. NPCA's tech note adds a consolidation caution: do not over vibrate fiber-reinforced concrete, because fibers can sink to the bottom of the form.
Steel or synthetic for an exposed fence panel?
Synthetic fibers avoid the one cosmetic problem steel fibers bring to an exposed panel. NPCA's tech note says galvanized or stainless steel fibers exposed at the surface can show small reddish spots over time, which poses no risk to durability but is not attractive. Precast Today describes synthetic macrofibers as non-magnetic and non-corrosive, suited to exterior precast where aesthetics matter, and says they generally need five to 10 times less weight of material than steel fibers.
How do you test a fiber mix in a precast yard?
A precast yard can compare fiber mixes with ASTM C1399, which the white paper calls possibly the best test method for precasters. C1399 uses 4 in. by 4 in. by 14 in. beams and can be run without the closed-loop servo-hydraulic machine that ASTM C1609 requires, so it suits relative comparisons and quality control rather than design values.
Specimen preparation matters. The white paper says fiber specimens should be consolidated with external vibration whenever possible, that internal vibration is discouraged and that rodding is not permitted, because both can leave fibers unevenly distributed. Slump is still measured the ordinary way, with ASTM C143.
Reinforcement, mix and tooling are planned together on a new fence line. Our mold systems page describes Elastoquip's urethane gang, rail, post and cap molds for producers setting one up.
Frequently asked questions
Do precast concrete fence panels need fibers?
Not by default. The National Precast Concrete Association says that without a specification calling for fibers, or a handling stress or shrinkage cracking problem to solve, there may be little advantage to adding them.
What is the difference between microfibers and macrofibers?
NPCA defines microfibers as less than 0.3 millimeters in diameter, used for plastic shrinkage control and never to replace steel reinforcement, and macrofibers as greater than 0.3 millimeters, which can be considered as a replacement for structural steel where codes or project specifications allow.
Can fibers replace rebar in a precast fence panel?
Only through an engineered design. NPCA's Fibers White Paper says replacing reinforcing steel with fibers should be evaluated by a structural engineer to confirm the product complies with applicable codes and specifications.
Do fibers affect slump?
Yes. NPCA's rough estimate is about an inch of slump loss for every three pounds of fiber per cubic yard, and it recommends recovering workability with superplasticizers or mid-range water reducers rather than added water.
Talk to our team
Send us your panel design, production volume and cycle targets and we will recommend a mold configuration and concrete mix to match. Or browse the full mold system range and fence designs.
Contact Elastoquip